Privilege in internal investigations: protecting your communications

Oct 05 2026

White Collar Crime

How to safeguard legally privileged material and the mistakes that put it at risk

Legal professional privilege is the most powerful shield available to organisations facing regulator or enforcement action. It protects confidential communications between lawyer and client from compulsory disclosure to regulators, prosecutors, and opposing parties. Yet privilege is also fragile. It can be lost through carelessness, waived by inadvertent disclosure, and challenged by regulators who argue it was never properly established. In the high-stakes environment of a corporate investigation, getting privilege right is a strategic imperative.

What is legal professional privilege?

English law recognises two forms of legal professional privilege. Legal advice privilege which protects confidential communications between a lawyer and client made for the purpose of giving or receiving legal advice. Litigation privilege which protects confidential communications made for the dominant purpose of actual or reasonably contemplated litigation, provided there is a real prospect of adversarial proceedings.

The distinction matters. Under the House of Lords’ decision in Three Rivers District Council v Governor and Company of the Bank of England (No. 6), the “client” for the purposes of legal advice privilege may be limited to a defined group within the organisation authorised to seek and receive legal advice. This has significant practical consequences for internal investigations, where information is gathered from employees across the business.

Litigation privilege in internal investigations?

In Eurasian Natural Resources Corporation v Director of the Serious Fraud Office marked a significant development the Court of Appeal held that litigation privilege could attach to documents created during an internal investigation, even before a criminal investigation had been formally commenced, provided adversarial proceedings were reasonably in contemplation.

This decision broadened the practical scope of litigation privilege for corporates, but the boundaries remain contested. The “dominant purpose” test must be satisfied for each communication, and the threshold for “reasonable contemplation” of litigation requires careful analysis of the specific facts.

What are the most common mistakes?

  • Mixing legal and commercial advice in the same document. Where a communication serves a dual purpose, privilege will only attach if the dominant purpose is legal advice or litigation.
  • Failing to label documents. Whilst labelling a document “privileged and confidential” is not determinative, it is an important evidential marker.
  • Sharing privileged material too widely. Circulating a legal memorandum to external consultants without appropriate confidentiality agreements creates a real risk of waiver.
  • Ignoring the “client” question. Following Three Rivers (No. 5), information gathered from employees outside the authorised client group may not attract legal advice privilege.

Practical steps to protect privilege

  • Maintain clear, contemporaneous records of the purpose of each communication
  • Use separate channels for legal advice and commercial or operational matters
  • Explain the nature and importance of privilege (and who it belongs to) before investigation interviews
  • Consider the position of in-house counsel: are they acting as legal adviser, or in a broader commercial role?
  • Restrict the circulation of privileged material to those with a genuine need to know

How does AI help protect privilege?

AI-powered document review tools are transforming how legal teams manage privilege. These tools can rapidly identify and segregate potentially privileged material from large data sets, dramatically reducing the risk of inadvertent disclosure.

For lean legal teams and smaller specialist firms, this capability is a genuine game-changer: it enables a level of rigour and speed that was previously available only to the largest law firms with armies of junior reviewers.

AI classification can flag documents containing mixed legal and commercial content, highlight communications involving in-house counsel, and identify materials that may attract litigation privilege based on their context and timing.

The bottom line

Privilege is your organisation’s most valuable protection in an investigation, but it must be actively managed from the time that a decision is made to commence an investigation. A well-designed privilege strategy, supported by modern AI tools, can mean the difference between a controlled, defensible investigation and one in which your most sensitive communications are laid bare.

If you are considering an internal investigation and need guidance on privilege, contact us for specialist advice. Protecting your privilege starts on day one.

If you have any questions arising from this blog, please do not hesitate to contact us for advice, send us an e-mail, or, alternatively, follow us on X, Facebook, Instagram, or LinkedIn to stay-up-to-date.

Corporate investigations in the UK – blog series

This article is part of the Corporate Investigations in the UK blog series, exploring key legal, regulatory and practical considerations for businesses navigating corporate investigations. Read the full series below:

  1. Criminal misconduct in business: the first 48 hours
  2. Understanding regulator-led investigations in the UK
  3. Privilege in internal investigations: protecting your communications
  4. Self-reporting and cooperating with UK authorities: risks and rewards
  5. The role of the board during a corporate investigation

 

The information in this blog is for general information purposes only and does not purport to be comprehensive or to provide legal advice. Whilst every effort is made to ensure the information and law is current as of the date of publication it should be stressed that, due to the passage of time, this does not necessarily reflect the present legal position. Gherson accepts no responsibility for loss which may arise from accessing or reliance on information contained in this blog. For formal advice on the current law please do not hesitate to contact Gherson. Legal advice is only provided pursuant to a written agreement, identified as such, and signed by the client and by or on behalf of Gherson.

©Gherson 2026

 

View all news & Insights
Make an enquiry

Related Posts

  • Gherson contributes to GIR’s Practitioner’s Guide on Investigaitons with a chapter on cryptocurrency

    White Collar Crime

    November 6, 2026

    Gherson contributes to GIR’s Practitioner’s Guide on Investigaitons with a chapter on cryptocurrency

    Read more

  • Sanctioned at Home – the documentary series

    International Protection

    November 4, 2026

    Sanctioned at Home – the documentary series

    Read more

Request Legal Advice

If you require legal assistance please get in touch
Contact us